Monday, September 30, 2013

OPINION - Shields and Ponnuru 9/27/2013

"Shields and Ponnuru Discuss Government Spending Showdown, Iranian Relations" PBS Newshour 9/27/2013

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  Syndicated columnist Mark Shields and Ramesh Ponnuru, senior editor at The National Review, join Judy Woodruff to discuss the week's top news, including the standoff in Congress over a federal spending bill, consequences of a government shutdown, warming U.S. relations with Iran's president and a UN breakthrough on Syria.

MARK SHIELDS:  I think the (Iran) sanctions are hurting.

I think -- I'm encouraged.  I think that this is a chance to bring some stability in a region that we have seen our own influence quite limited.  Let's be blunt about it.  I mean, Iraq didn't turn out the way we hoped. Afghanistan didn't.  Democracy has not produced flourishing democracies around.

I mean, this is a hope to bring to a region that lacks stability some stability.  And I think there is a mutual self-interest at this point.
----
RAMESH PONNURU:  But with Syria, again, there are some reasons for skepticism, that -- does this resolution actually have teeth?  And you will note that it doesn't even actually call the regime to account for using chemical weapons.

JUDY WOODRUFF:  But there is language in there about consequences, isn't there?

RAMESH PONNURU:  But, again, the question is enforceability.  And, again, as with anything at the U.N., what are the Russians going to do if it comes to enforcing?

MARK SHIELDS:  The glass is more than half-full here.

This is the Security Council moving.  It isn't perfect.  It isn't ideal, but it is real progress.  The one reservation I have is, it leaves in power the status quo in Syria.  But we have learned over the last week, Judy, that the alternative is not terribly appealing in itself.

No comments: