Showing posts with label U.S. foreign policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label U.S. foreign policy. Show all posts

Monday, November 08, 2021

NICARAGUA - Demolished Democracy

COMMENT:  Daniel Ortega = Donald Trump, when it comes to demolishing democracy.

"How Daniel Ortega ‘demolished’ democracy in NicaraguaPBS NewsHour 11/5/2021

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  This Sunday, Nicaragua will hold an 'election' the United States calls a "sham."  President Daniel Ortega is seeking a fourth consecutive term and has made sure to silence the opposition before the first vote is cast.  He has locked up candidates and attacked critical media.  His inevitable victory has regional implications for U.S. hopes to strengthen democracy.  Nick Schifrin reports.



AFGHANISTAN - Pose Taliban Takeover Economy

"Dwindling aid, crumbling economy and ISIS add to Afghans’ hardships under Taliban rulePBS NewsHour 11/5/2021

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  It's been nearly three months since the Taliban takeover of Afghanistan, and the country is in economic and humanitarian free fall.  Special correspondent Jane Ferguson was in Kabul during the U.S. withdrawal in August, and has returned to report on the dire situation that has developed since.  She joins Judy Woodruff with more.  This report was made with support from the Pulitzer Center.



Tuesday, August 31, 2021

AFGHANISTAN WAR - The Last Day


"Final Troops Withdraw from Afghanistan, Ending Evacuation -- and the War" by Stephen Losey and Steve Beynon, Military.com 8/30/2021

The U.S. military's evacuation from the main airport in Kabul has ended -- along with the nearly 20-year war in Afghanistan.

U.S. Central Command head Gen. Frank McKenzie said Monday the last C-17 Globemaster III took off minutes before midnight Kabul time -- the beginning of Aug. 31, which was the United States' deadline for withdrawal.  For the first time since late 2001, weeks after the Sept.  11 attacks, there are now no U.S. service members in Afghanistan.

"There's a lot of heartbreak associated with this departure," McKenzie said.  "We did not get everybody out that we wanted to get out, but I think if we'd stayed another 10 days, we wouldn't have gotten everybody out that we wanted to get out."

Reports of celebratory gunfire from the Taliban surfaced online after the final C-17 took off from Kabul.

The final weeks of the war were among the military's hardest, as thousands of troops rushed in to hold Hamid Karzai International Airport as the U.S.-backed Afghan government collapsed with shocking speed and the Taliban rapidly filled the void.

The unprecedented airlift effort to rush to safety Americans and Afghan allies -- the largest noncombatant evacuation operation in U.S. military history -- saw some 123,000 people evacuated in all.  Since Aug. 14, more than 79,000 civilians were ferried out by the U.S. military on one flight after another -- primarily C-17s, their massive cargo bays at times packed with hundreds of refugees.

The evacuation effort saw the last flag-draped coffins from the war arrive at Dover Air Force Base in DelawareThe final U.S. casualties came Aug. 26, when a suicide bomber struck at the airport's Abbey Gate, packed with U.S. troops and many Afghans trying to get through.  The bomber killed 13 troops -- 11 Marines, a sailor and a soldier, wounded more than 20 other troops, and killed or wounded hundreds of Afghans.

It marked one of the deadliest days of the war for the U.S., with less than a week to go, and brought the final toll of service members killed there to 2,461.  There were also more than 20,000 troops wounded in Afghanistan.

"My heart is broken over the losses we sustained three days ago," McKenzie said.

The Islamic State's Afghanistan branch, ISIS-Khorasan, or ISIS-K, claimed responsibility for the attack.  The U.S. responded with two drone strikes: one on Friday that killed two people the military claimed were ISIS organizers, and one on Sunday it said targeted a car in Kabul carrying explosive material intended for another attack.  The latter airstrike may have resulted in up to 10 civilian casualties, according to reporting by The New York Times that was not immediately disputed by the Pentagon.

ISIS-K and the Taliban are in the midst of their own war, prompting a pseudo-alliance between the U.S. and the Taliban, who have been killing one another for 20 years.  McKenzie described the Taliban as "pragmatic," saying the terror group had a vested interest in the U.S. leaving quickly, thus motivating it to try and facilitate a smooth withdrawal by securing areas outside of the airport.

He added that diplomatic efforts to help remaining U.S. citizens and eligible Afghans who want to leave will continue, though the military's role in the evacuation process is done.

Just as the evacuation began, the desperation of some Afghans hoping to escape impending Taliban rule caused an accident that pushed the White House to send in more troops to secure the airfield.  On Aug. 16, many desperate Afghans ran onto the airport's grounds and surrounded a C-17 that had just landed to unload equipment.  The C-17's crew, concerned about the crowd of people approaching the aircraft, opted to take off again.  Afghans ran alongside the plane and clung to its sides, some falling to their deaths, and the body of one Afghan was later found in the aircraft's landing gear.

Maj. Gen. Chris Donahue, commander of the 82nd Airborne Division, and U.S. Ambassador Ross Wilson were among the last U.S. officials to leave Afghanistan.  They departed on the final C-17 flight, covered by what McKenzie described as "overwhelming U.S. airpower overhead, should there have been any challenge to our departure."

At the peak of the airlift last week, C-17s were taking off roughly every 45 minutes, and more than 19,000 people were flown out on a single day.  On average, the military evacuated more than 7,500 civilians per day, McKenzie said.

The U.S. military evacuated more than 6,000 American civilians, which the Pentagon said represented the majority of those who wanted to leave.  The military estimated that only a few hundred wishing to leave remain.

McKenzie said the civilian evacuation ended about 12 hours before the final withdrawal.  Some equipment was brought out on the final flights, but other equipment -- such as the Counter Rocket Artillery and Mortar, or C-RAM, system and various aircraft and vehicles -- was left behind permanently disabled.

The sudden collapse of Afghanistan's American-backed government, and the emergency evacuation triggered by the deteriorating security situation, have drawn both political attacks for opponents of the Biden administration, and finger-pointing within.  Roughly 2,500 U.S. troops had remained in Afghanistan when the Trump administration left office, a number the Biden administration reduced to about 650 before the Taliban easily conquered Afghanistan.

President Joe Biden quickly mobilized 6,000 troops, including the 10th Mountain and 82nd Airborne Division, to secure the airport and aid in the evacuation that followed.

"No words from me could possibly capture the full measure of sacrifices and accomplishments of those who serve, nor the emotions they're feeling at this moment," McKenzie said.  "But I will say that I'm proud that both my son and I have been a part of it."



Monday, June 28, 2021

THE ABANDONMENT OF AFGHANISTAN - Taliban Expansion

"Taliban gains Afghan territory, may seek ‘complete return to power’ amid US withdrawalPBS NewsHour 6/21/2021

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  The U.S. military will soon complete its withdrawal from Afghanistan after 20 years of war.  But the Afghan government is under constant attack from the Taliban and is struggling to hold onto its territory.  This past weekend saw some of the militants' largest gains yet.  Nick Schifrin and Scott Worden, director of Afghanistan and Central Asia at the U.S. Institute of Peace think tank, explain.



Monday, May 24, 2021

VIEW FROM SOUTH KOREA - Denuclearizing North Korea

"South Korea’s foreign minister on US role in denuclearizing North KoreaPBS NewsHour 5/20/2021

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  President Joe Biden is expected to meet Friday with South Korea’s President Moon Jae-in.  The two leaders are at very different points of their terms.  Biden newly-elected, and Moon in his final year.  They are expected to discuss progress on North Korea, and discuss tense U.S.- China relations.  Amna Nawaz gets the details from South Korean Foreign Minister Chung Eui-yong.



THE NEVER ENDING WAR - Updates

PERSONAL COMMENT: As I said in the past, the Never Ending War between Israel and Palestinians will never end UNTIL the Palestinian People tell their governments to stop AND the People of Israel tell their government to stop.  No one outside, no outside government, can really do anything.  Although outside governments can make things worst.

"Families faced with death, destruction amid Israeli-Hamas conflict in GazaPBS NewsHour 5/17/2021

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  The battle between the Israeli military and Hamas militants has now entered a second week, as calls mount for an immediate cease-fire.  So far, the violence has killed more than 200 Palestinians in Gaza, and another 10 people in Israel.  That comes as the United Nations estimates more than 38,000 Palestinians have been forced to flee the airstrikes.  Stephanie Sy reports.

 

 

"Palestinians strike to protest Israeli military action in Gaza, but no cease-fire in sightPBS NewsHour 5/18/2021

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  John Yang reports on the ongoing crisis in the Middle East as calls for a ceasefire are ignored and destruction spreads as Palestinian rocket fire and Israeli artillery attacks continue on day nine with no let-up in sight.

 

 

"Egypt indicates a truce agreement between Israeli and Hamas forcesPBS NewsHour 5/19/2021

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  Israel and Hamas forces in Gaza may be edging closer to a cease-fire after 10 days of open war.  Egyptian mediators say there's a truce agreement, in principle.  A top Hamas official said he expects fighting to stop in a day or two.  Pressure to end the conflict built today, with 227 Gazans and 12 Israelis killed so far.  John Yang reports.

 

 

"Can Biden walk the line between support for both Israel and Palestine?PBS NewsHour 5/19/2021

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  For decades, the U.S. has supported Israel, backing up its defense policy and supplying tens of billions of dollars in aid and weapons.  Now, some within the Democratic party are questioning that support, and challenging President Biden's handling of the Gaza conflict.  John Yang speaks to Daniel Brumberg, director of democracy and governance studies at Georgetown University about the matter.

 

 

"A look at the US role and reaction to cease-fire in the Middle EastPBS NewsHour 5/20/2021

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  A cease-fire is at hand in the war between Israel and Hamas.  Word of the truce came Thursday from Israel, and Hamas quickly agreed.  If it holds, it would end 11 days of fierce fighting that killed at least 230 Palestinians and 12 Israelis, and wrecked Gazan cities.  John Yang begins the report, and Yamiche Alcindor joins Amna Nawaz to discuss the Biden administration's role and reaction.

 

 

"A look at the humanitarian crisis wrought by Israel-Hamas warPBS NewsHour 5/20/2021

Excerpt

Correction:  In this segment, we referred to Refaat Alareer as “Refaat Aljareer” on first mention.  We also mistakenly referred to Diana Mushtaha as attending the University of Houston, instead of the University of Texas.  NewsHour regrets the errors.

SUMMARY:  John Yang reports on life on the ground for Palestinians and Israelis caught in the crossfire of war, and how US pressure on the region’s leaders has affected civilians, and Middle Eastern immigrant communities in the US.

 

 

"Both Israel and Hamas claim victory after truce, bringing prospect of peace into questionPBS NewsHour 5/21/2021

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  The shooting has stopped, but the war of words goes on as Israel and Hamas offered sharply different appraisals Friday of who won and who lost their fourth conflict in just over a dozen years.  John Yang reports on day one of the ceasefire.

 

 

"The fragile ceasefire between Israeli forces and Hamas seems to be holdingPBS NewsHour 5/22/2021

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  The cease-fire between Israeli forces and Hamas held for a second day.  Meanwhile, Gazans returned to their homes to survey the damage as UN humanitarian relief officials said rebuilding health facilities was a high priority because of the coronavirus pandemic.  NPR correspondent Daniel Estrin joins to discuss.



Monday, February 22, 2021

PRESIDENT BIDEN - Foreign Policy Shift

"In foreign policy shift, Biden lifts terrorist designation for Houthis in YemenPBS NewsHour 2/16/2021

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  The Biden administration on Tuesday officially lifted the designation of the Iranian-backed Houthis in Yemen as a global terrorist organization.  That announcement comes within a larger review of the U.S. relationship with Saudi Arabia.  Nick Schifrin reports on the prospects of diplomacy, and speaks to Timothy Lenderking, the new U.S. Envoy to Yemen, to learn more.



Monday, July 27, 2020

AMERICA vs CHINA - Chinese Consulate Ordered to Close

"Why the U.S. ordered a Chinese consulate closed — and what it means for foreign policyPBS NewsHour 7/22/2020

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  The Trump administration has ordered China to close its Houston consulate -- the latest action in an escalating fight between the two countries.  The State Department cited concerns about espionage and intellectual property theft as justification for the move.  Nick Schifrin reports and talks to Yale Law School’s Susan Thornton, former acting Assistant Secretary of State, and author Gordon Chang.



Monday, September 09, 2019

AFGHANISTAN - Peace Talks vs Attacks

"Amid peace talks, Taliban claims deadly explosion in Kabul" PBS NewsHour 9/2/2019

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  In Afghanistan, the Taliban claimed responsibility for a massive explosion that rocked Kabul, killing at least five and wounding 50.  It targeted the heavily secured area that’s home to several aid agencies and international organizations, and came as the U.S. envoy briefed the Afghan government on a draft peace deal.  Special correspondent Jane Ferguson joins Judy Woodruff with the latest.




"In Afghanistan, the Taliban uses violence as leverage during peace negotiations" PBS NewsHour 9/3/2019

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  In the Afghan capital of Kabul, 16 people died in a car bomb Monday night.  A compound housing mostly international workers was the target, and the Taliban claimed responsibility even as they participate in peace talks with the U.S.  Why has there been a “massive uptick in violence” recently, and what might the tentative peace deal include?  Special correspondent Jane Ferguson joins Judy Woodruff.




"What’s next for U.S.-Afghanistan peace talks?" PBS NewsHour 9/8/2019

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  President Trump announced on Twitter on Saturday that he had canceled a secret Camp David meeting with the Taliban and Afghan officials, after the insurgent group “admitted” to a suicide attack in Kabul that killed 12 people, including a U.S. soldier.  The Wall Street Journal’s Kabul bureau chief, Craig Nelson, joins Hari Sreenivasan to discuss the road ahead in ending America’s longest war.



Monday, July 22, 2019

TROUBLED ALLIANCE - U.S.-Turkey

"Where U.S.-Turkey relations stand after dispute over purchase of Russian missiles" PBS NewsHour 7/17/2019

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  The White House announced Wednesday that the U.S. will not sell billions of dollars of next-generation fighter planes to Turkey, after the NATO ally purchased advanced Russian surface-to-air missiles.  Amna Nawaz talks to Admiral James Stavridis, who served as NATO's top military officer from 2009 to 2013, about what these latest developments mean for U.S.-Turkey relations that were already tense.

TRUMP EGO - 'Deal of the Century?'

Again, this 'never-ending-war' will not be resolved by outsiders.  It can only be resolved when the people of Palestine, AND the people of Israel, demand that their governments stop the tit-for-tat war.

"Why Trump thinks this is the moment to resolve Israeli-Palestinian conflict" PBS NewsHour 7/17/2019

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  U.S. presidents have long tried, and failed, to resolve the decades-old [40 yrs] Israeli-Palestinian conflict.  In June, President Trump’s team unveiled the first part of its peace plan, an economic proposal.  The plan’s all-important political component is yet to come.  Judy Woodruff speaks with Jason Greenblatt, a former Trump real estate lawyer helping lead the U.S. effort, about what’s at stake.

Monday, May 20, 2019

OPINION - Shields and Brooks 5/17/2019

"Shields and Brooks on abortion law battles, 2020 generational divide" PBS NewsHour 5/17/2019

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  Syndicated columnist Mark Shields and New York Times columnist David Brooks join Judy Woodruff to discuss the week’s political news, including the role of foreign policy in the upcoming Presidential election, restrictive new abortion laws, polling for Presidential candidates and a generational divide in the Democratic Party.

Judy Woodruff (NewsHour):  And with that, we turn to the analysis of Shields and Brooks.  That is syndicated columnist Mark Shields and New York Times columnist David Brooks.

Gentleman, hello.

Mark Shields, syndicated columnist:  Judy.

Judy Woodruff:  So, you have listened to the conversation with Congresswoman Gabbard.

David, to you first. 

How much of a role is foreign policy going the play in this election?

David Brooks, New York Times:  Well, at the moment, I don't think a primary role.

I was a foreign correspondent in the early '90s covering sort of Europe, Africa and the Middle East.  And I remember, when the Clinton campaign started, suddenly, all my stories about these foreign policy issues disappeared off the American consciousness, because, when Clinton came in people said, something is happening right here.

And, right now, the focus of voters' attention is the crisis right here.  And so I think that's the way it is.  It could change with one foreign policy crisis.  It could all change.  But, right now, this is a pretty domestically focused nation.

Judy Woodruff:  So, for Congresswoman Gabbard, I mean, Mark, as you heard her say, she's very focused on, what does the U.S. do, what's its role in the world, mistakes have been made.

Is that a way to capture voters' imagination, I guess is what I'm asking.

Mark Shields:  Well, it is if, in fact, David is right and an issue or crisis does develop.

And I think we can see crises brewing at this point.  George H.W. Bush, I think it's fair to say, in 1988, his foreign policy credentials, his own military experience, were strong credentials in his election, John Kerry's nomination in 2004.

And Barack Obama, being the only Democratic candidate who had opposed the United States' war in Iraq was — that was his calling card.  That was his credential.  So, I mean, if in fact it's there, it becomes central, if it isn't.  It wasn't in 1992.

So, a lot of — just quickly, David, a lot of comment right now about how the President has handled North Korea, Venezuela, Iran.  So, do we see that being a plus or a minus for the President?

(CROSSTALK)

David Brooks:  Well, I would say the big minus is the way he's frayed all our alliances, which makes all those issues harder.

But his general posture is one of sometimes extreme bellicosity, with no convincing idea that he's actually going to do anything about these things.  And so I think we're not very far — we're not very close to a war in Iran.

I think he's loathe to do that.  He'd be crazy to do that.  But he is responding to a situation, which is a tough situation.  If the intelligence reports are true that the Iranians told their militant armies that they sort of control in the region to target Americans, then that's something any American President is going to respond to.

I'm not sure you can respond as well when you have no allies, or you can respond as well as when you have already walked out of the Iran deal.  You have sort of left yourself in a hard place.

And the thing that worries me is, the administration seems to think Iran is on the verge of folding, and that if they just up the pressure, get a little more erratic, then Iran will fold.  Most experts I know do not think they're that close to folding, and we could be in a situation where things spiral.

Judy Woodruff:  Mark, let's turn to a domestic issue that a lot of people are talking about right now.

And that is the anti-abortion movement moving essentially state after state in the last few weeks and months to impose even stricter limits on abortion, in the case of Alabama, the strictest limits in the country, basically saying all abortions are illegal.  Doctors could go to prison.

What do you see is going on here?  I mean, what does this movement say to you?  And do you think one political party or another — I mean, setting — obviously, it's a serious issue.  But setting the issue itself aside, does one political party or another stand to lose from this?

Mark Shields:  Yes.  Yes.

I would say that, first of all, the issue itself is thorny and unresolved in the country, and remains so, after some 45 years, unlike the country's moved considerably to the left or liberal position on gay rights, on same-sex marriage.

Abortion has been stuck in — the Gallup poll has asked the same question annually.  Do you consider yourself pro-choice or pro-life?  The most recent, 48 percent of Americans considered pro-life, 48 percent pro-choice.

But Lydia Saad of Gallup writes — and I think she's right — there is a consensus on this thorny, difficult issue on three aspects, on the life of the mother, should abortion be available and optional in the case of the life of the mother.

Judy Woodruff:  Right.

Mark Shields:  And 71 percent of those who identify as pro-life say it should be, so seven out of 10.  And the same thing by a simple majority — it's not quite that high — on the question of a pregnancy as a result of rape or incest.

So I would say, in answer to your question, Judy, that, politically, this is a — it's — I don't want to say a suicide pact for Republicans.  Republicans are very much on the defensive.  And it will put them in a position where all those Democratic House seats that were won in 2018 in places like Pennsylvania, New Jersey got a lot tougher for — uphill for Republicans to win back.

David Brooks:  Yes, I'm not sure.

I mean, New York started this by passing a very liberal abortion law, which went all the way through the pregnancy.

Mark Shields:  That's right.

Judy Woodruff:  Right.

David Brooks:  Virginia, there was one that was proposed that didn't end up going anywhere.

And so I — the polling data I look at has three positions.  One, do you think abortion should always be legal?  And you get like 27 percent.

Mark Shields:  Yes.

David Brooks:  Should never be legal, 18 percent.  Should be legal, which the European solution, which is just legal first trimester, harder the second, 50 percent.

And that 50 or 55 percent has — as Mark says, has been very stable since Roe v. Wade.  And — but the problem is, we took it out of politics, so we couldn't get to the moderate position.  Now the extremists have taken over both sides.

And everybody is speaking for these extreme position.

(CROSSTALK)

Judy Woodruff:  But I was just going to say, right now, it's the restrictive side that is having success in legislature after legislature.

David Brooks:  Right.  Well, in the red states, yes.

Judy Woodruff:  Right.

Mark Shields:  I think David — both in Virginia and New York, the Democrats were seen, unfavorably and unfortunately, and I think wrong, as a party of infanticide.  I mean, they really were.

I mean, Ralph Northam, that's what got him into initial trouble.

Judy Woodruff:  The proposal that was put forward and then withdrawn.

Mark Shields:  That's exactly right.

But now I think there's no question that it's the Republican dominant position.  That's why Kevin McCarthy, the Republican House leader, has tried to distance himself.  He realizes this — this is a killer in suburban America.

And America remains pro-choice and anti-abortion.

David Brooks:  It's like what the NRA did to the gun issue, these people are doing to the abortion issue.

Mark Shields:  Yes.  That's right.  Yes.

Monday, April 08, 2019

TURKEY - Tense Allies

"Turkish foreign minister slams U.S. for having ‘no clear strategy’ on Syria" PBS NewsHour 4/3/2019

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu slammed the United States’ Syria strategy and Middle East peace plan, saying Wednesday that one was underdeveloped and the other might not exist.

“It seems that there is no clear strategy yet” by the U.S. to dial back its military presence in Syria, Cavusoglu said in an interview with PBS NewsHour anchor and managing editor Judy Woodruff.

Cavusoglu said Turkey was getting different signals from President Donald Trump and other U.S. departments, including the military.  Trump tweeted last December that the United States was withdrawing all of its troops from Syria, but since then he has gradually dialed back that declaration and committed to keeping a residual force in the country.

Turkey’s foreign minister also said he doubted the existence of a U.S. peace plan for Israel and the Palestinians — an effort that Trump’s son-in-law and White House adviser Jared Kushner has been leading for the U.S..  “Until today, there is no peace plan,” Cavusoglu said.  “We are not sure whether there will be.”

He added that Trump’s decision to move the U.S. embassy in Israel from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem showed the President’s bias towards Israel.  Trump’s recent policy change recognizing Israel’s sovereignty over the Golan Heights, which Israel seized from Syria during the Six-Day war in 1967, was another decision that “everybody has been concerned about,” Cavusoglu said.

“Everybody believes the U.S. is no longer a balanced or objective leader on the world stage, he said.

Monday, February 04, 2019

EUROPEAN UNION - Helping Iran?

"Why the EU is helping Iran avoid U.S. sanctions" PBS NewsHour 1/31/2019

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  U.S. withdrawal from the Iran nuclear deal in 2018 meant that Iran didn't receive some of the billions of dollars of economic benefits it was promised when it entered the agreement.  Now, France, Germany, and the U.K. have formed a company intended to direct funds and goods to Iran, bypassing U.S. sanctions.  Nick Schifrin talks to David O’Sullivan, EU Ambassador to the U.S., about their motivation.

VENEZUELA - U.S. Intervention?

"Will U.S. intervention in Venezuela help or harm its people?" PBS NewsHour 1/30/2019

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  In Caracas, a revitalized Venezuelan opposition braved physical threats to demand that national assembly head Juan Guaidó replace President Nicolás Maduro.  The Trump administration is backing Guaidó, but critics question whether U.S. intervention will help the country’s suffering population.  Nick Schifrin talks to former Venezuelan diplomat Isaías Medina and the Woodrow Wilson Center’s Ben Gedan.

Monday, January 07, 2019

WAR AGAINST ISIS - Latest Civilian Death Estimates

"‘Systemic shortfalls’ obscure true civilian cost of U.S. airstrikes against ISIS" PBS NewsHour 12/31/2018

Excerpt

SUMMARY:  The U.S.-led coalition fighting ISIS in Iraq and Syria released its latest estimate of civilians killed by U.S. airstrikes since 2014.  Over the past four years, 1,139 civilians were killed by accident.  But how was this figure calculated, and is it accurate?  Larry Lewis of the Center for Naval Analyses, a former official at the Defense and State Departments, joins Nick Schifrin to discuss.