Thursday, July 15, 2010

AFGHANISTAN - Local Defense Forces, Good Idea or Not?

"Afghans to Form Local Forces to Fight Taliban" by ALISSA J. RUBIN, New York Times 7/14/2010

Excerpt

After intensive negotiations with NATO military commanders, the Afghan government on Wednesday approved a program to establish local defense forces that American military officials hope will help remote areas of the country thwart attacks by Taliban insurgents.

Details of the plan are sketchy, but Americans had been promoting the force as a crucial stopgap to combat rising violence here and frustration with the slow pace of training permanent professional security forces — the bottom-line condition for the American military to begin pulling back from an increasingly unpopular war. Many parts of Afghanistan have no soldiers or police officers on the ground.

Over 12 days of talks, Gen. David H. Petraeus, the new NATO commander, overcame the objections of President Hamid Karzai, who had worried that the forces could harden into militias that his weak government could not control. In the end, the two sides agreed that the forces would be under the supervision of the Afghan Interior Ministry, which will also be their paymaster.

Given the history of Afghan tribalism, could Karzai's objections be legitimate? Could these local defense forces come under the control of local warlords NOT loyal to the central government?

No comments: