Wednesday, February 26, 2014

AMERICA - Exploiting Temp Workers

"U.S. Lags Behind World in Temp Worker Protections" by Michael Grabell, ProPublica 2/24/2014

Excerpt

‘Permatemping’ cases highlight lack of U.S. protections for temp workers. Other countries limit the length of temp jobs, guarantee equal pay and restrict dangerous work.

For nearly six years, Limber Herrera has toiled as a temp worker doing the same work for the same company in Mira Loma, Calif.  About 40 hours a week, he unloads shipping containers for NFI—one of the largest freight distribution firms in America—moving goods that will eventually stock the shelves of Walmart and Sam’s Club.

Herrera, 30, has been a temp so long that he’s outlasted the agency that hired him.  But that mattered little.  One day in late 2012 he was called into the break room to fill out some paperwork.  Then he went back to work—only now employed by the temp agency that took over the contract.

If Herrera worked in South Korea, his temporary assignment would be limited to two years, after which the company would have to hire him as a regular employee.  If he worked in Germany, he would be guaranteed the same wages and working conditions as employees hired directly by the company.  And if he worked in Chile, his temp agency could be shut down if it failed to pay him his wages or put him in harm’s way.

But Herrera works in the United States, which has some of the weakest labor protections for temp workers in the developed world, according to data compiled by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), which produces research on behalf of 34 of the world’s industrialized nations.

Since the 2007-09 recession, temp work has been one of the fastest growing segments of the economy.  But a ProPublica investigation into this burgeoning industry over the past year has documented an array of problems.  Temps have worked for the same company for as long as 11 years, never getting hired on full-time.  Companies have assigned temps to the most dangerous jobs.  In several states, data showed that temps are three times more likely than regular workers to suffer amputations on the job.  And even some of the country’s largest companies have relied on immigrant labor brokers and fly-by-night temp agencies that have cheated workers out of their wages.

In contrast, countries around the globe have responded to similar abuses by adopting laws to protect the growing number of temps in their workforces.  These include limiting the length of temp assignments, guaranteeing equal pay for equal work and restricting companies from hiring temps for hazardous tasks.

“The lack of basic protections for temporary workers in this country is shameful,” Rep. George Miller, the ranking Democrat on the House Education and Workforce Committee, said in a statement.  “It is important that the U.S. examine some of these provisions and consider whether they can serve as models for statutes to help protect American workers.”

Herrera’s is an extreme case of “permatemping,” hiring a temp for years to do the same job permanent employees do, but without the benefits and protections.  A former construction worker during the housing boom, he desperately needs the work to support his family, but believes the practice is exploitive.

“I think that workers, everyone, deserves to have a good job hired directly by a company with good benefits,” said Herrera, who has a 5-year-old daughter and 3-year-old son.

Having strong labor laws on the books doesn’t necessarily mean they’re enforced.  For example, Brazil has some of the world’s strictest temp worker regulations.  But it also has an enormous underground economy in which workers are paid informally and abuses go unchecked.  And a country’s protections for its temp workers may not apply to guest workers brought in from other countries for major construction projects or domestic work.

Still, the OECD statistics – which rank the United States 41st among 43 developed and emerging economies – show the types of legislation available for protecting temp workers who federal and state officials say are among the most vulnerable.

No comments: